Illuminations

Essential media about the arts
Producer and publisher of television, films and DVDs
Spread from LIFE with Dorothea Lange image; © Time Inc

Just back from filming in China, I'm starting to think about the run-up to Christmas. Tomorrow I'll post a China wrap-up; other topics for the coming couple of weeks include news of our new performance production, more about Hamlet (but nothing today) and responses to drama DVDs, including The Henrik Ibsen collection (available in or from the USA) and the new Alan Bennett at the BBC. Today I want to wander along an online trail about Dorothea Lange's photography, but as usual I'm also keen to encourage your comments about stage productions or films that you've seen recently -- or other things that you think might be of interest. And to give you a taste of what we're hoping for, take a look at the great posts by Zoe, Debbie and Lisa last week.

For the rest of the post, I want to re-run an online journey. In itself, it's far from remarkable and the hopping from link to link that I describe is the kind of thing we all now do without thinking. But once again I was struck this morning by how the internet has profoundly changed -- and enhanced -- even the reading of a single article, and how it has created the potential of new forms of discovery and learning. I recognise that pointing this out will seem naive (of course everyone knows this), but there are times when I think it's worth pausing to recognise how thrilling these possibilities are.

Here's where I started: Tyler Green's always interesting blog Modern Art Notes and the post A season of books on Dorothea Lange. Green's post highlights Jonathan Raban's article American Pastoral for the New York Review of Books which reviews two recent books about the photographer Dorothea Lange. Lange (there's a Wikipedia entry here) is best known for her photographs in the 1930s for the US Farm Security Administration and in particular for an image, reproduced in the Raban piece, known as Migrant Mother, taken in Nipomo, California in 1936.

You can find and download Migrant Mother (as I did) at the Library of Congress Archive, along with a discussion about and detailed bibliography for the image together with a rights statement indicating that because it was produced for a government agency it's a public domain image and its use is unrestricted. There's also an unretouched version of the image (before a thumb was removed) along with other variants made of the subject.

Back to Raban. At the top of his article he references William Emson's 1935 book Some Versions of Pastoral which explores the sixteenth- and seventeenth-century poems about shepherds and the like, idealising 'the lives of the poorest people in the land'. And Raban goes on to suggest that the pastoral is a key strand in American culture, underpinning Fenimore Cooper, Bret Harte, the films of John Ford and the paintings of Frederic Remington.

The chief loci of American pastoral have been the rural South and the Far West, while most of its practitioners have been sophisticated easterners for whom the South and West were destinations for bouts of adventurous travel. They went equipped with sketchpads and notebooks in which to record the picturesque manners and customs of their rustic, unlettered fellow countrymen.

Thus, for Raban, the work of Dorothea Lange -- and especially Migrant Mother.

The picture defines the form of pastoral as Empson meant it, and the closer one studies it, the more one's made aware of just what a queer and puzzling business it is. A woman from the abyssal depths of the lower classes is plucked from obscurity by a female artist from the upper classes and endowed by her with extraordinary nobility and eloquence... It's a portrait in which squalor and dignity are in fierce contention, but both one's first and last impressions are of the woman's resilience, pride, and damaged beauty.

Raban develops these ideas in a rich review of tw new volumes about Lange, Dorothea Lange: A Life Beyond Limits by Linda Gordon and Anne Wiston Spirn's Daring to Look: Dorothea Lange's Photographs and Reports from the Field. In the course of his richly interesting essya he also discusses a photo-essay that Lange shot in Ireland 1954. And in a supplementary NYR Blog post he shows How to Find the Best of Lange. Including the LIFE article Irish Country People, a detail of which I have reproduced above, in the LIFE archive hosted by Google.

I've enthused frequently here about this online archive, and its liberal policy of allowing the personal use of its images, but I hadn't realised that it contains digitised (and indexed) versions of every page of every issue from 23 November 1936 to 29 December 1972. Every page -- including (as you can see with Mars above) all the advertisments. This is, simply and straightforwardly, an incredible research resource -- and one in which you quickly find you've spent an hour or two just browsing. You can, for example, find another photo-essay by the figure LIFE calls Miss Lange, about Mormon towns in the USA. from 6 September 1954 co-photographed by Ansel Adams.

Oakland Museum holds the Dorothea Lange archive and the Online Archive of California has many of its images and other materials online (although the user-friendliness of the facility could be enhanced). Then there are many more images online in the Library of Congress' Prints and Photographs holdings. So the opportunities for your own supplementary research are manifold.

Now, it happens that Migrant Mother also features in another recent online discussion of photography -- a compelling seven-part series on filmmaker Errol Morris's Zoom blog at the New York Times site. Morris is an acute photography critic and in the past month he's been exploring the dust bowl photographs of Lange, Walker Evans and others. His focus has been the extent to which these images were 'faked' and for the final post he interviews photographer Bill Ganzel.

In 1974 Ganzel began a project to revisit many of the scenes of the FSA photographs and to interview some of their subjects -- including the women in Migrant Mother, Florence Thompson. She was snapped by Ganzel in a comparatively prosperous suburban backyard, along with her three daughters, but she also recalled the context in 1936 in which the photograph was taken.

[W]e started from L.A. to Watsonville. And the timing chain broke on my car. And I had a guy to pull into this pea camp in Nipomo. I started to cook dinner for my kids, and all the little kids around the camp came in. “Can I have a bite? Can I have a bite?” And they was hungry, them people was. And I got my car fixed, and I was just getting ready to pull out when she [Dorothea Lange] come back and snapped my picture.

If you're still with me, there's a full Wikipedia page about Florence Owens Thompson, together with a host of further references. But by now you've got the idea -- or more probably, given up. I've had a fascinating morning following these references -- and I know I've learned things in ways that I woiuld never have been able to a decade ago. Which is precisely why, when I think that this is just a single thread of a vast repository of knowledge, I'm entirely happy to apply the word thrilling -- and to feel that we shouldn't simply take the possibilities of this for granted.

Image: a detail from a LIFE magazine spread featuring the opening page of a Dorothea Lange photo-essay about Ireland (and an advertisment for Mars). This 21 March 1955 issue of LIFE is available via the LIFE archive hosted by Google; © Time Inc.

Comments

Jill (08 November 2009 7:53 pm)

Welcome back, John! I've enjoyed reading your and John M's blog entries for your trip. How many minutes of broadcast TV will the filming translate to?

Thank you for organising an excellent commentary trio for the Hamlet DVD. I know this is last week's news but I never got around to posting then.

Spoiler for 'Six Characters in Search of an Author' -

I've mentioned my fondness of DVD commentaries before, I think. This production certainly hit my buttons. Some way through the second part, the play started again from the beginning (well - almost the same) but with an accompanying director's DVD commentary!! This is where I really started to get lost but it was so entertaining, I didn't care!

End of spoiler.

Last week, I saw Twelfth Night at Stratford with some good performances and gorgeous to look at. It was great to see Sam Alexander again, as Sebastian. He's very talented at comedy and Sebastian and Viola's reunion was moving. Antonion's get up (the sailor who rescues Sebastian) - long, braided hair and draped clothes - gave me the impression of an ancient Gaul - hundreds of years out of time! I expect it was in keeping with the period of all the other costumes but I did find it puzzling.

I'm looking forward to 'Inherit the Wind' with Kevin Spacey and David Troughton. Should be apt subject matter for today and two wonderful actors.




CeCe (08 November 2009 8:28 pm)

Hi Gang ! I've been trying to catch up with all that's been going on since I went on holiday - you never realise how much can happen in 3 weeks !

I was starting to panic about whether I was going to be able to get tickets for 12th Night, but luckily I have managed it ! I will be there on Thurs 12th (coincidentally!!) Nov, so if any of you are there .... :-)

Bit peeved that the Beeb in its wisdom thought 12.20 pm last night was a good time to put Al Pacino's version of 'Merchant of Venice' on ... :-~ I tried my best, but had to give in at 1.30 am...

Other than that, I have nothing else to comment on, but I just wanted to poke my head round the door as it were !

Buzz (08 November 2009 8:28 pm)

WOW! John sounds like you have had an Amazing time!

I'm going to see Twelth Night on Tuesday, can't wait! Anyone else going?

John Wyver (08 November 2009 8:42 pm)

Good to be back -- thanks for the comments -- couple of quick responses:

@ Jill: Art of Faith II will be 3 55-minute films, to be shown next year on Sky Arts; we've done the filming in Japan and China now, with an India trip in January (Seb's doing that one) and a trip to Angkor Wat and Borobadur (me again).

@ CeCe: have you seen that, remarkably for a movie, The Merchant of Venice is on iPlayer at the moment?

Ruth (08 November 2009 8:54 pm)

@John. Thanks for the heads-up about Merchant of Venice on i-player. There was no way I was staying up that late to watch it and my set top box won't record anything that crosses 1am properly :(.

Have you had any thoughts about a new project for the viewing group?

CeCe (08 November 2009 8:59 pm)

Thank you John !! re the iplayer note
Thank you John !! re posting my 'Looking for Richard' comments You're a star :-)

Caroline (09 November 2009 11:44 am)

Thanks for the 'heads up' re Merchant of Venice @CeCe and @John. Is it my imagination, or are more films making it on to iPlayer recently?
Maybe I have just noticed them more for some reason......

I'm hoping to see 12th Night in London in the New Year - so I look forward to hearing any more reviews :)

Nicola (09 November 2009 1:02 pm)

Welcome back John!

I had a quick jaunt up to visit our RSC friends up in Newcastle this weekend. We originally booked for the Comedy of Errors friends event (tea with the cast) but then struggled to find tickets to the actual performance. Thankfully, a last minute RSC angel came to our rescue and we saw the show afterall (from the gallery).

I thoroughly enjoyed it and it was great to see how they adapted it for a younger audience. I particularily liked Sophie Russell's tap dancing nun, the wooden spoon puppet show, Mariah Gale's bluesy song (with the rest of the cast as backing dancers!) and the general use of on stage music performed by the cast throughout the show. The children really got into it, and it was lovely to see them interacting with the cast during the preshow walkabout (the cast wander about the stage setting up, waving at the kids & walking about the stalls some too). I hope I'll be able to fit in another performance of it next year, to see it from the stalls.

Afterwards we headed to the postshow event and there was a quick question and answer session before we alll had a drink and a few biscuits (@CeCe there were sadly no gingernut or dinos to be found). I had a quick chat with Richard Katz and Dyfan Dwyfor and praised both As You Like It and The Drunks. Richard thought The Drunks might make it up to Newcastle, fingers crossed. I spoke to Mariah Gale too (first time we've properly spoken, though I did bump into her in Chichester after seeing Edward Bennett & Sam Alexander in Hay Fever ealier this year). She was lovely, of course.

Richard also told me that Romeo & Juliet, which I am very much looking forward to, starts rehearsals next week. Understudies haven't been determined yet (I enquired as I have understudy tickets too) though he thought Dyfan (main part being Peter) may be doing Romeo (Dyfan himself was, I think, unaware of this!)

I'm seeing Twelfth Night on the 21st (final night in Stratford), can't wait :)

CeCe (09 November 2009 7:35 pm)

@ Nicola :-) :-) Can't believe you didn't take any with you ! :-)

Nicola (10 November 2009 8:40 am)

@CeCe Well, I didnt want anyone to think I was weird or anything. I had a quick chat with Jonjo too, he recognised me (I should think so, too).

Lisa (11 November 2009 11:58 am)

I saw 12th night on Monday and really liked it it was better (funnier) than the London one altho Derek Jacobi was fantastic as Malvolio, as was Samantha Spiro as Maria.

Feste was easier to understand in the RSC production. A lot of the time in the Jacobi one I didn't understand him whereas in the RSC one they kinda made a joke out of that.

I also met James Ellroy on Saturday - he's one of my favourite writers and I was so excited to meet him almost as good as meeting Tennant! He apologised again for making the Cold Six Thousand so hard to read (I have never been able to get thru that one!) and signed my copies of American Tabloid and My Dark Places.

I was equal parts thrilled and scared to meet him (if you've read his books or seen his documentaries, you'll know he's a little bit intense, to say the least) but he was really sweet in person, smiling and chatting to people, getting his photo taken. So Weird!! (His nickname is the Demon Dog of American Literature and he did mention that Mike Tyson was afraid of him)

Can't wait to get started on Blood's A Rover now!

Leave a reply

Favorite Posts

'Both at the first and now...' [Updated]
Initial previews for Hamlet, plus other reactions and blogs

Blogging the Bard
Links to all the Hamlet posts

Blogging the Bard II: Macbeth
A round-up of posts from making Macbeth

China 18: that's a wrap(-up)
All the posts from China

Towards 2016: [3] the Big Idea
The campaign starts here for a quatercentenary Complete Works

For the poet Brian Jones
A brief appreciation of the poet and teacher

Latest Entries

Masterful minimal Macbeth
Thames Television's version of Trevor Nunn's production

Sunday links
The death of Margaret Dale, the light of films and...

Unwelcome 'ghosts'
The '79 Macbeth: a suitable case for digital treatment?

Terribly, terribly good
Four Granada productions of Noel Coward from 1964

»